82
See all 82 photos
$590,000
Est. payment /mo
3 Beds
2 Baths
2,860 SqFt
Price Dropped by $59K
357 Coffeen AVE Sheridan, WY 82801
REQUEST A TOUR If you would like to see this home without being there in person, select the "Virtual Tour" option and your agent will contact you to discuss available opportunities.
In-PersonVirtual Tour
UPDATED:
Key Details
Property Type Other Types
Listing Status Active
Purchase Type For Sale
Square Footage 2,860 sqft
Price per Sqft $206
Subdivision South Park
MLS Listing ID 26-569
Style 1.5 Story
Bedrooms 3
Abv Grd Liv Area 700
Year Built 1902
Annual Tax Amount $1,455
Tax Year 2025
Contingent Inspection
Lot Size 8,000 Sqft
Source Sheridan County Board of REALTORS®
Property Description
A nationally published historic restoration offers a rare opportunity to own a truly one of a kind property. Available fully furnished, as a successful turnkey vacation rental, or a blank canvas ready for your own vision, the choice is yours. Currently operating as a highly successful Airbnb, this remarkable home blends timeless historic character with modern comfort, offering exceptional flexibility as a private residence, investment property or both. Built by George Herbert Benham in 1915, who worked for the Bighorn Lumber Company, this remarkable residence has been thoughtfully refurbished and restored to its original glory as a historic City of Sheridan structure. Step inside to a welcoming open floor plan filled with beautiful original woodwork and trim. Timeless details include charming window seats, a telephone niche, and warm, inviting living spaces rich with historic character. Mission and Craftsman-style lighting fixtures were thoughtfully selected throughout the home to complement the architecture and preserve the authenticity of the period. Antique period hardware can be found throughout the home, further enhancing the historic character and attention to detail woven into every space. The kitchen honors the home's history while offering modern convenience, featuring a restored 1934 Magic Chef stove, a 1931 GE Monitor Top refrigerator, and a Fisher & Paykel drawer dishwasher discreetly hidden behind custom wood panels. The original cabinetry remains intact and has been carefully restored, while the kitchen backsplash features classic subway tile that complements the historic character of the home. In keeping with the commitment to preservation, each of the 46 windows has been individually removed, repaired, and reglazed to maintain the integrity and craftsmanship of the property. An inviting eat-in breakfast nook complements the kitchen, creating the perfect space for an early morning cup of coffee, while the formal dining room, complete with the original built-in buffet, lends itself to more elegant gatherings and entertaining. The bathrooms continue the historic charm of the residence, featuring carefully selected period pieces, including beautiful clawfoot tubs that reflect the elegance and craftsmanship of the era. A huge basement offers endless possibilities for additional living space, hobby areas, or simply exceptional storage capacity. Even the outdoor landscaping has been thoughtfully designed to reflect the historic era of the home. The front yard features native, low-maintenance landscaping supported by a drip irrigation system, blending beauty with practicality. A one-car garage is complemented by ample additional parking access from the alleyway, offering flexibility for extra vehicles, guests, or recreational storage. Enjoy this extraordinary property as your private residence or continue operating it as a charming and successful historic Airbnb destination. This is a rare opportunity to own a fully restored and thoughtfully curated piece of Sheridan history. Please ask the listing agent for a complete document outlining all upgrades and restoration work completed on the home, along with a personal property inventory list detailing the items that will remain with the property. Additionally, please request copies of the Old House Journal. All measurements are approximate. https://benhamjohnstonbungalow.com/
Location
State WY
County Sheridan
Community South Park
Direction Turn left at at the intersection of S Main St and Coffeen Ave. House will be on the left.
Rooms
Basement Full
Interior
Interior Features Breakfast Nook
Heating Natural Gas, Hot Water
Flooring Hardwood
Exterior
Garage Spaces 1.0
Garage Description 1
Fence Fenced
Utilities Available Cable Available, Phone Available
Roof Type Asphalt
Porch Covered Deck, Deck, Patio
Building
Sewer Public Sewer
Water Public
Architectural Style 15 Story
Structure Type Lap Siding
Schools
Elementary Schools School District #2
Middle Schools School District #2
High Schools School District #2
Others
Senior Community No
Listed by ERA Carroll Realty, Co., Inc.
Nearby Locations
GET MORE INFORMATION